DENNIS SCHWARTZ 
IS THERE ANY GOOD 
IN SAYING 
EVERYTHING ABOUT A MOVIE?

 
ONE HOUR WITH YOU (director: Ernst Lubitsch; screenwriters: adaptation of the play Only a Dream by Lothar Schmidt/Samson Raphaelson; cinematographer: Victor Milner; editor: William Shea ; music: Oscar Straus/lyrics by Leo Robin; cast: Maurice Chevaller (Dr. Andre Bertier), Jeanette MacDonald (Colette Bertier), Genevieve Tobin (Mitzi Oliver), Charles Ruggles (Adolph), Roland Young (Professor Olivier), George Barbier (Police Commissioner), Josephine Dunn (Mile. Martel), Richard Carle (Detective), Charles Judels (Policeman), Barbara Leonard (Mitzi's maid), Donald Novis (Singer of title song); Runtime: 78; MPAA Rating: NR; producer: Ernst Lubitsch; Criterion Collection: Eclipse Series 8; 1932)

 
"It amiably follows along the tracks of the usual Lubitsch frothy boudoir operetta."

Reviewed by Dennis Schwartz

German émigré Ernst Lubitsch ("Monte Carlo"/Design for Living"/"The Shop Around the Corner") helms this musical remake of his silent The Marriage Circle (1924). It was directed first by George Cukor under Lubitsch's supervision, as ordered by Paramount before his contract was up even though Lubitsch was at the time shooting The Man I Killed. Not satisfied with the way the comedy portions were shot, Lubitsch re-shot the film and successfully sued to get full credit as director to Cukor's chagrin. It's based on the play "Only A Dream" by Lothar Schmidt and the screenplay is by Samson Raphaelson. It amiably follows along the tracks of the usual Lubitsch frothy boudoir operetta and is again about marital infidelity.

It's set in spring, in Paris. Dr. André Bertier (Maurice Chevaller) and his wife of three years Colette (Jeanette MacDonald) are still happily married. Colette's flirtatious school chum, Mitzi Olivier (Genevieve Tobin), visits and makes a serious play for André. He tries to resist, but in one of his many asides to the audience exclaims that he's only human. When the Bertiers hold a dinner party, André switches place cards with Mlle. Marcel in order to avoid sitting next to Mitzi. Colette mistakenly thinks hubby is chasing after Mlle. Marcel, and it leads to the scheming Mitzy getting André to her apartment for some romance. Mitzy's professor husband (Roland Young) hired a private detective to follow her and uses the infidelity to file for a divorce. To get even with André, Colette gets his best friend Adolph (Charles Ruggles) to admit kissing her and thereby in her eyes making the husband and wife's infidelities equal. The couple then ask the rhetorical question to the audience, "What would you do?" Their answer is an embrace. 

The songs were not that great, but nevertheless were fitting and lively. They include: "But Spring is Here," "What a Little Thing Like a Wedding Ring Will Do," "We Will Always Be Sweethearts," "Three Times a Day," "One Hour With You," "It Was Only a Dream Kiss," "We Will Always Be Sweethearts" and "What Would You Do?". 

REVIEWED ON 2/19/2008        GRADE: B

Dennis Schwartz: "Ozus' World Movie Reviews"

© ALL RIGHTS RESERVED   DENNIS SCHWARTZ

http://www.sover.net/~ozus/index.htm