EVERYTHING ABOUT A MOVIE?
|NANA (director/writer: Jean Renoir; screenwriters: Pierre Lestringuez/from the novel by Emile Zola; cinematographers: Edmund Corwin/Jean Bachelet; editor: Jean Renoir; music: Marc-Olivier Dupin; cast: Catherine Hessling (Nana), Jean Angelo (Count de Vandeuvres), Werner Krauss (Count Muffat), Valeska Gert (Zoe), Claude Moore (Fauchery), Pierre Champagne (Hector de la Faloise), André Cerf (The Tiger), Pierre Lestringuez (Bordenave), Raymond Guérin-Catelain (Georges Hugon), Jacqueline Ford (Rose Mignon), Karl Harbacher (Francis), Jacqueline Forzane (Comtesse Muffat); Runtime: 130; MPAA Rating: NR; producer: Jean Renoir; Lionsgate; 1926-silent-France-in French with English subtitles)|
lesser film that hints at the
potential greatness of young filmmaker Jean Renoir...
Reviewed by Dennis Schwartz
A lesser film that hints at the potential greatness
young filmmaker Jean Renoir ("La
Marseillaise"/The Little Match Girl"/"The Elusive
as his ability to film theater
spectacle, his detailed observations of class manners,
his astute study
of his developed characters, his uncanny skill in
comedy and tragedy, and his ability to provide
elaborate set designs
(marvelously designed by future director Claude
Autant-Lara, who had a
minor part billed as Claude Moore). This early theater
piece silent is
based on the celebrated novel by Emile Zola.
Let down by the hammy and one-dimensional performance of its doll-like star, Catherine Hessling, Renoir's wife at the time. She's a diminutive and rather unappealing actress, who never heard of subtlety. Hessling is miscast as the temptress, who makes men of position and wealth disgrace themselves for her beauty (if you find her credible in that role, you must have seen something I couldn't see happening onscreen). The supposed pleasure is in seeing this self-absorbed, vain, unconscionable pleasure-seeker, after ruining the lives of a number of aristocrats, get her comeuppance in the conclusion when abandoned as she comes down with a fatal case of smallpox.
Though many regard it
Renoir's finest silent, I had a hard time sitting
lighthearted first hour without looking at my watch.
When things turned
considerably bleaker in the last part, I only felt
overlong and overwrought melodrama was ending at last.
It chronicles nasty
slum girl Nana rise from a struggling third-rate
variety show actress,
popular with the vulgarian plebeian theater audience
as a sexpot tart
flapper, to the wealthy courtesan of the following:
married Count Muffat (Werner Krauss), the wealthy
racing horse owner
Count de Vandeuvres (Jean Angelo) and
his lovelorn twit of a nephew Georges (Raymond
these men throw away their lives to be with such an
annoying and not
very attractive woman like Nana might have worked in
the novel as a
serious psychological work, but onscreen it mostly
and opera-like farcical.
The lavish pic is set
during the Second
The critics at its
theater release mostly
panned it and the public didn't buy into it, as it
flopped at the
REVIEWED ON 1/4/2010 GRADE: C+
Dennis Schwartz: "Ozus' World Movie Reviews"
© ALL RIGHTS RESERVED DENNIS SCHWARTZ