DENNIS SCHWARTZ 
IS THERE ANY GOOD 
IN SAYING 
EVERYTHING ABOUT A MOVIE?

 
GODS AND MONSTERS (director/writer: Bill Condon; cinematographer: Stephen M. Katz; editor: Virginia Katz; cast: Ian McKellen (James Whale), Brendan Fraser (Clayton Boone), Lynn Redgrave (Whale's housekeeper, Hanna), Lolita Davidovich (Boone's girlfriend, Betty), David Dukes (David Lewis), Jack Plotinick (Mr. Kay), Rosalind Ayres (Elsa Lanchester), Jack Betts (Boris Karloff); Runtime: 105; Regent Entertainment; 1998-UK)

 
"Whale, always the aesthete and snob, comments to an interviewer that the other Frankenstein films were done by hacks."

Reviewed by Dennis Schwartz

James Whale (Ian) is the son of working class parents in north England who escaped his early poverty to become a successful director, and is noted for his famous monster films. He directed the original Frankenstein (31), The Bride of  Frankenstein (35), The Old Dark House (32), and The Invisible Man (33)---which was his personal favorite. Whale, always the aesthete and snob, comments to an interviewer that the other Frankenstein films were done by hacks. He also did some films that weren't horror, most notable is the classy musical Showboat (36), and his most inauspicious one is The Road Back (37).

Whale died of mysterious circumstances in his Hollywood pool in 1957. This film clears up that mystery (at least, hypothetically) and probes into his homosexual life. He liked to be called Jimmy by friends and is seen in his last few weeks alive but living with the ill effects of a stroke that makes him either forgetful when medicated or when non-medicated seeing a lot of images at once, as if it were thunderstorms in the sky in the form of violent hallucinations from the past.

What highlights this film and makes it propelled on a high octane level, is the bravura physical performance of Ian McKellen. His presence onscreen as a swish personality is much like a few other great performances accomplished recently about gifted artistic and intellectual English queers; Derek Jacobi as the artist Francis Bacon in Love is The Devil and John Hurt's performance of a fictionalized stuffy professor in Love and Death on Long Island.

To gain access to what this fictionalized but mostly real-life film is about one has to look at Jimmy as a homosexual, whose every movement is influenced by the lust he craves for men and how cunning he is in trying to entice them as we see him at his playful best in the splendor of his tasteful home. Here he is being nursed by the heavily foreign accented housekeeper (Redgrave) who wears her cross over her apron in earnest, fearing Jimmy's sins of the flesh will take him to hell. Yet she finds in herself the strength to disapprove of his behavior, but still is his most trustworthy caretaker for the last 15-years. Redgrave is wonderfully dour in her supporting role.

If it is fear or disgust of homosexuals that repels you this film will displease you, even though its overt physical sex is minimized. Yet every nuance of the film and all its projections are about what a queer is like. For openers we have a pesty and patronizing film college student (Plotinick) who comes over to interview him, not interested in his homosexuality but in those horror films he made famous. Jimmy handles him with bemusement; life is but a strip poker game he gleefully says. And since the student's questions leave Jimmy feeling cold he suggests that they make things interesting, at least, for Whale, by having the student strip off a piece of clothes for any question asked; and, in response, Whale promises to answer any question honestly. This scene turns out to be an hilarious comedy routine, probably capturing Whale's devilish personality as well or better than the more dramatic scenes did.

The serious focus of the film will become the strange relationship that will develop between the new gardener for the Whale house, Clayton Boone (Brendan), who looks like Adonis. He has caught the director's roving eye, focusing in on his muscular arms and his tattoo from his marine days of "Death Over Dishonor." Jimmy charms and beguiles him, knowing full-well that this stud is all heterosexual. Yet he feels very comfortable talking to the brutish Clayton and loves the chase more than the conquest. Clayton seems like a very nice and naive young man, but will come across later on as a young man with a lot of pent-up feelings and in need of a fatherly figure to talk to. Clayton is anything but literary never even having heard of Whale before, just as Whale is hardly your prototypical father figure. But Whale opens up with Clayton and becomes nostalgic about his life and his films more so than with the film student who really knew his films, but was just perceived by Whale as a user of people. It seems that there was probably some repressed psychological need in Whale to be accepted by certain types of people, which is why he devotes so much time to the uninspiring Clayton; it was as if he needed to have his approval to be gay.

And Clayton gets to like the old man, despite what he can't stand about him sexually, glad that he met someone who is famous or at least was at one time.

What is most impressive and understated, is the comic tone and lightness of Whale. It was much like the tone Whale used in his horror films which he used to hide the real fear of death people have and their antagonism for monsters, whom Whale simply adored and would never make fun of. He comes across as debonair at all times, even when in the middle of a mild stroke and terribly witty in the ways of Hollywood's gays.

The only animated sexual delight from him comes by way of his ex-lover, the Hollywood producer, David Lewis (David), who after a particularly dry conversation welcoming Whale back home after his stroke kisses Whale intimately on the lips as he departs the house.

During Whale's somewhat voluntarily retirement from Hollywood, not induced by any scandal -- as Whale is quick to remind his interviewer -- that it was the studio who ruined his career. They blamed him for the failure of The Road Back which they interfered with unmercifully ruining any chance of success that film may have had. He therefore retreated to his amateur passion for drawing when he couldn't get the kind of films he wished to direct. He uses these drawings to lure Clayton into his studio, getting him to pose for a drawing of just his head.

There is Whale as the charmer, which is what this film personifies best. We see him telling Hollywood stories and talking of his WW1 experiences, which are enhanced by the hallucinations he is having of those events. We, also, see him nested comfortably at home with his florid flower garden and the Olympic-sized pool in the background, which he never uses for himself but welcomes men to swim there in their natural comfort.

Reactions to Whale, as to whether you care for him or not, come about from how the participants in his life view his films. Clayton must somehow see something in them that affects him greatly, since he still poses for him despite being unappreciative of his homosexuality. It might be that he wants something more than the money he is being paid to pose. He wants something from him that he is not quite sure that he can articulate. What both these men need is to get things off their chest, to talk to someone who can listen to them with some empathy, as they both suffer from an interminable loneliness and an emotional poverty of childhood: one with too many stories to tell, living a life of an upper-class gentleman, pretending to be something he was not born into, but not caring about these pretenses anymore with Clayton who is far removed from the circle of people he moves in. So, he easily lets his hair down with him. And then there is Clayton, whose feelings have not been tapped into, who can only be a listener without any stories to tell. Perhaps, both are drawn to each other because they don't travel in the same circles and can relax with each other since no false representations of themselves are really needed.

Real Hollywood figures are portrayed in the way Whale probably saw them, with his so-called monsters (Boris Karloff and Elsa Lanchester) there is a frank and polite distance as their friendliness seems genuine enough; there is a keen recognition that their fame is linked together. While for the closet homosexual Hollywood director, George Cukor, there is no love lost, as Whale expresses his displeasure at him for being a pushy upstart. He flashes back to the nude boy parties the hypocritical Cukor was secretly known for giving. We see how distant they seemed at meeting again in Cukor's mansion, at a rather dull party to honor Princess Margaret (which never happened in real-life). Whale takes Cukor's cold reaction to him without any visible anger, but shows a great deal of hidden resentment at Cukor for getting to direct a lot of the better films that he wanted for himself.

For all its wonderful performances and charm and probative look into the gay Hollywood world, this is not a very important film in the sense that it has little to say about the creative experience. It has a lot to say about how a queer  can maneuver his way around the Hollywood of the past as long as he didn't make a big show out of his sexual predilections. Condon has very ably directed a likable and witty film on a very low budget, that makes its subject seem much greater than it is. It is as if Jimmy Whale invited us over for some iced tea and cucumber sandwiches, and he told us a few things about himself and the filming of his Frankenstein movie before he got tired and all. So all we had left to ponder was the materialism and memories he was surrounded by, and how tired and painful life has become as he wishes for a mercy killing at the hands of Clayton. But since he couldn't bring that about, he instead jumps into his pool of seduction and drowns himself.

And what we learned from this biopic is that Jimmy Whale was a gentleman, a lecherous and cunning one but still a gentleman of the old school; and, for most of us, we got to know him better than we ever did before, via this splendidly done and excellently researched film.

It is apparent that Whale has this tremendous identification with outcasts (monsters). Therefore it seems logical to deduce that for those who liked this film, it really came down to how well they responded to an outsider like Whale. When Clayton saw the Frankenstein movie on TV for the first time with his ex-girlfriend Betty, he gravitated toward the film; Betty saw it as passe, something that wasn't cool enough for her to enjoy.

REVIEWED ON 5/8/99      GRADE: B+

Dennis Schwartz: " Ozus' World Movie Reviews "

© ALL RIGHTS RESERVED   DENNIS SCHWARTZ

http://www.sover.net/~ozus/index.htm